Navigating the complex world of sales tax in the U.S.? Discover how origin based sales tax states shape your business obligations and compliance strategies—with clarity, precision, and real-world impact.
What Are Origin Based Sales Tax States?
In the United States, sales tax is not governed by a single federal system but rather by a patchwork of state and local regulations. Among these, a critical distinction lies in whether a state follows an origin-based or destination-based sales tax model. In origin based sales tax states, the tax rate applied to a sale is determined by the seller’s location—the point where the transaction originates—rather than where the buyer receives the goods.
This model simplifies tax collection for businesses operating within a single jurisdiction but can create complications when selling across county or state lines. Understanding this framework is essential for any business engaged in retail, e-commerce, or interstate commerce.
Definition of Origin Based Sales Tax
Origin based sales tax refers to a system where the applicable sales tax rate is based on the seller’s physical location at the time of sale. This means that if a company is headquartered or has a nexus in a particular city or county, all taxable sales—regardless of where the customer is located within the state—are taxed at the rate of that origin jurisdiction.
For example, if a business in Oklahoma City sells a product to a customer in Tulsa, and Oklahoma is an origin based sales tax state, the transaction is taxed at Oklahoma City’s combined state and local rate, not Tulsa’s. This contrasts sharply with destination-based systems, where the buyer’s location dictates the tax rate.
- Tax rate is tied to the seller’s location
- Applies primarily to intrastate sales
- Simplifies compliance for local-only sellers
“The origin-based model reduces administrative burden for small businesses operating within one jurisdiction, but it can distort tax equity when sales cross local boundaries.” — Tax Foundation, 2023
How It Differs From Destination Based Taxation
The key difference between origin and destination based sales tax states lies in the geographic point of reference used to calculate tax. While origin-based systems use the seller’s location, destination-based systems use the buyer’s shipping or delivery address.
Most U.S. states have moved toward destination-based taxation, especially after the landmark South Dakota v. Wayfair, Inc. (2018) Supreme Court decision, which allowed states to require out-of-state sellers to collect sales tax. This shift was driven by the need to level the playing field between brick-and-mortar stores and remote sellers.
In contrast, origin based sales tax states maintain a more traditional, location-centric approach. This can lead to situations where customers in high-tax areas purchase goods from low-tax areas and effectively avoid higher local rates—a phenomenon sometimes referred to as “tax shopping.”
- Origin: tax follows seller’s location
- Destination: tax follows buyer’s location
- Destination model dominates modern e-commerce policy
List of Current Origin Based Sales Tax States
As of 2024, only a handful of U.S. states operate under a fully origin based sales tax system for intrastate transactions. These states apply the tax rate of the seller’s location when the buyer is within the same state. It’s important to note that even among these states, rules can vary significantly based on municipality, county, and type of product.
Understanding which states fall into this category is crucial for businesses managing multi-state sales tax compliance. Let’s explore the current origin based sales tax states in detail.
Michigan: A Hybrid Approach
Michigan is often cited as an origin based sales tax state, but its system includes nuances. For most sales, Michigan applies the tax rate based on the seller’s location—making it origin-based. However, local taxes (such as those imposed by cities or counties) may still be influenced by delivery location in certain cases.
The state’s Single Business Tax (now replaced by the Michigan Business Tax) historically supported this model, and current practices reflect that legacy. Retailers with physical stores or warehouses in Michigan must collect tax based on the rate at their place of business.
- Mainly origin-based for state and local sales tax
- Some exceptions for specific jurisdictions
- Remote sellers with nexus follow origin rules
For more information, visit the Michigan Department of Treasury.
Ohio: Complex Local Rules
Ohio operates under an origin based sales tax system for intrastate sales, meaning the tax rate is determined by the seller’s location. However, Ohio’s system is complicated by its numerous local taxing jurisdictions—over 600 special purpose districts with their own tax rates.
While the base state rate is 5.75%, local rates can push the total tax rate above 8%. Because Ohio uses the origin model, a seller in a low-tax township can sell to customers in high-tax cities without charging the higher rate—unless the seller has a physical presence (nexus) in the destination jurisdiction.
“Ohio’s origin-based system creates incentives for businesses to locate in low-tax areas to gain competitive pricing advantages.” — Ohio Tax Policy Council, 2022
Learn more at the Ohio Department of Taxation.
Pennsylvania: Mostly Origin-Based With Exceptions
Pennsylvania is generally considered an origin based sales tax state, applying the combined state and local rate of the seller’s location. The state rate is 6%, and local rates vary depending on the municipality.
However, Pennsylvania makes exceptions for certain types of sales, such as those made at temporary locations (e.g., fairs or festivals), where the tax is based on the event’s location. Additionally, businesses with multiple locations must register each site separately and apply the correct local rate for each.
- Standard intrastate sales use origin-based rates
- Temporary sales events taxed at destination
- Local rates vary by city and county
See the Pennsylvania Department of Revenue for official guidance.
How Origin Based Taxation Affects E-Commerce
The rise of e-commerce has dramatically changed the landscape of sales tax collection, especially for origin based sales tax states. While the origin model was designed for a pre-internet economy where most sales were local, today’s digital marketplace challenges its relevance and fairness.
For online sellers, understanding how origin based sales tax states impact pricing, compliance, and customer experience is essential to avoiding penalties and maintaining profitability.
Challenges for Online Sellers
Online businesses operating in origin based sales tax states face several unique challenges. First, they must determine whether they have established nexus—physical or economic—in a given state. If they do, they are required to collect sales tax based on the origin rules.
However, because many online sellers operate from a single warehouse or headquarters, they may inadvertently under-collect tax when selling to customers in jurisdictions with higher rates. This can lead to audit risks and back-tax liabilities if the state later determines that the seller should have collected more.
- Difficulty tracking multiple local rates at origin
- Risk of under-collection in high-tax destination areas
- Compliance burden increases with physical expansion
“E-commerce has exposed the limitations of origin-based systems, which were never designed for nationwide digital sales.” — National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL)
Impact on Pricing and Competition
Origin based sales tax states can create competitive imbalances. A seller located in a low-tax area can offer lower final prices than a competitor in a high-tax area—even if both are selling the same product.
This price advantage can distort market competition and incentivize businesses to relocate to jurisdictions with favorable tax rates. For consumers, it may encourage cross-border shopping—either physically or online—to avoid higher local taxes.
Moreover, this dynamic can reduce tax revenue for high-tax municipalities, leading to calls for reform toward destination-based models that ensure tax is paid where consumption occurs.
- Sellers in low-tax zones gain pricing edge
- Local retailers may lose business to out-of-town sellers
- Municipalities lose revenue due to tax avoidance
Tax Nexus and Its Role in Origin Based States
Nexus—the legal connection between a business and a state—plays a pivotal role in determining tax obligations in origin based sales tax states. Without nexus, a business is generally not required to collect or remit sales tax, regardless of the state’s tax model.
However, once nexus is established, the rules of the origin based sales tax states come into play, requiring sellers to collect tax based on their own location’s rates.
Physical Nexus vs. Economic Nexus
Physical nexus refers to a tangible presence in a state, such as an office, warehouse, employee, or retail store. In origin based sales tax states, establishing physical nexus triggers the obligation to collect sales tax at the rate of the business’s location.
Economic nexus, on the other hand, is based on sales volume or transaction thresholds. Following the Wayfair decision, many states—including some origin based sales tax states—have adopted economic nexus standards (e.g., $100,000 in sales or 200 transactions annually).
While economic nexus is more commonly associated with destination-based states, origin based sales tax states like Michigan and Ohio also apply it. This means that even remote sellers without a physical presence may be required to collect tax—if they meet the economic threshold—based on the rate at their home jurisdiction.
- Physical presence triggers tax collection duties
- Economic nexus expands obligations beyond physical borders
- Origin states apply economic nexus inconsistently
How Nexus Triggers Tax Collection in Origin States
Once nexus is established in an origin based sales tax state, the seller must register with the state’s tax authority and begin collecting sales tax at the rate applicable to their location.
For example, if a company in Columbus, Ohio (with a total sales tax rate of 7.25%) establishes economic nexus due to exceeding $100,000 in sales to Ohio customers, it must collect 7.25% on all taxable sales to Ohio residents—even if those customers live in Cleveland, where the rate is 7.75%.
This creates a situation where the state collects less tax than it would under a destination model, potentially affecting local government budgets that rely on sales tax revenue.
“Nexus rules have transformed sales tax compliance, making it essential for businesses to monitor both physical and economic thresholds across states.” — Avalara, 2023 State of Sales Tax Report
Explore nexus rules at Avalara’s Sales Tax Guide.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Origin Based Systems
The origin based sales tax model offers both benefits and drawbacks, depending on the perspective—be it the business, the consumer, or the government. While it simplifies compliance for local sellers, it raises concerns about fairness, revenue equity, and adaptability to modern commerce.
Let’s examine the pros and cons in detail.
Benefits for Businesses
One of the primary advantages of origin based sales tax states is simplicity. Businesses only need to know and apply one tax rate—the rate at their location—regardless of where their customers are within the state.
This reduces the need for complex tax software or third-party compliance tools, especially for small businesses with limited resources. It also minimizes errors in tax calculation and reporting.
- Single tax rate simplifies accounting
- Lower compliance costs for local sellers
- Reduced risk of miscalculation
Additionally, businesses in low-tax areas gain a competitive pricing advantage, which can boost sales and profitability.
Criticisms and Economic Impacts
Critics argue that origin based sales tax states undermine tax fairness and local revenue stability. When consumers buy from sellers in low-tax jurisdictions, high-tax municipalities lose out on revenue that would otherwise fund public services like schools, roads, and emergency response.
This can lead to a “race to the bottom,” where cities compete by lowering their tax rates to attract businesses, ultimately reducing overall tax capacity. It also creates inequities between local brick-and-mortar stores and remote sellers.
Furthermore, the model is ill-suited for the digital economy, where location is increasingly abstract. As more commerce moves online, the relevance of the seller’s physical location diminishes.
- Undermines local government revenue
- Creates unfair competition
- Outdated in the age of e-commerce
“The origin-based system is a relic of the 20th century. In a digital economy, consumption—not production—should determine tax liability.” — Brookings Institution, 2021
Recent Legal and Policy Developments
The legal landscape for sales tax in the U.S. continues to evolve, driven by technological change, court rulings, and legislative action. While origin based sales tax states have maintained their systems, they are not immune to pressure for reform.
Recent developments highlight the tension between traditional tax models and the realities of modern commerce.
Impact of the Wayfair Decision
The 2018 Supreme Court decision in South Dakota v. Wayfair, Inc. was a watershed moment for sales tax policy. It overturned the previous requirement that a business must have a physical presence in a state to be required to collect sales tax.
While Wayfair primarily empowered destination-based states to collect tax from remote sellers, it also influenced origin based sales tax states. Several of these states updated their laws to include economic nexus provisions, expanding their reach beyond physical borders.
However, the decision did not force origin states to switch to destination-based models. As a result, businesses selling into origin states may still collect tax based on the seller’s location—even if the seller is out-of-state.
- Wayfair enabled economic nexus in origin states
- No mandate to adopt destination-based models
- Increased compliance complexity for multi-state sellers
Read the full ruling at Supreme Court of the United States.
State-Level Reforms and Proposals
In recent years, some origin based sales tax states have considered shifting to destination-based models. Ohio, for instance, has seen legislative proposals to reform its system, though none have passed as of 2024.
Advocates for reform argue that destination-based taxation is fairer and more aligned with economic reality. They point to states like Texas and California, which successfully manage complex destination-based systems with the help of automation and centralized tax authorities.
However, opposition remains strong, particularly from businesses in low-tax areas that benefit from the current system. Political and economic inertia makes large-scale reform unlikely in the near term.
- Ohio and Michigan have debated reform
- No major shifts as of 2024
- Automation tools reduce need for systemic change
Compliance Tips for Businesses in Origin Based States
For businesses operating in origin based sales tax states, staying compliant requires careful planning, accurate record-keeping, and ongoing monitoring of tax laws. Whether you’re a small retailer or a growing e-commerce brand, these strategies can help you avoid penalties and ensure smooth operations.
Registering With State Tax Authorities
The first step in compliance is registering with the appropriate state tax agency. In origin based sales tax states like Michigan, Ohio, and Pennsylvania, sellers must obtain a sales tax permit before collecting tax.
Registration typically involves providing business details, location information, and expected sales volume. Once approved, the business receives a tax ID number and must file regular returns—monthly, quarterly, or annually, depending on sales volume.
- Register before making taxable sales
- Obtain a sales tax license or permit
- Keep registration updated with address or ownership changes
Visit National Association of State Fiscal Administrators for state contact information.
Using Tax Automation Software
Even in origin based sales tax states, tax rates can vary by city, county, and special district. Manually tracking these rates is error-prone and time-consuming.
Tax automation software like Avalara, TaxJar, or Vertex can help businesses accurately calculate, collect, and remit sales tax. These tools integrate with e-commerce platforms and accounting systems, reducing the risk of non-compliance.
For businesses with multiple locations, automation ensures that each site applies the correct origin-based rate, even if they operate in different tax jurisdictions within the same state.
- Automate tax rate calculations
- Integrate with Shopify, WooCommerce, QuickBooks
- Generate audit-ready reports
“Over 70% of mid-sized e-commerce businesses use tax automation to manage compliance across states.” — Forrester Research, 2023
Staying Updated on Law Changes
Sales tax laws are constantly changing. Origin based sales tax states may update their rates, expand nexus rules, or modify exemptions without notice.
Businesses must stay informed through official state websites, industry newsletters, and professional advisors. Subscribing to tax alerts from state revenue departments or joining trade associations can provide early warnings of upcoming changes.
- Monitor state tax authority websites
- Subscribe to compliance newsletters
- Consult with a tax professional annually
What are the main origin based sales tax states?
The primary origin based sales tax states are Michigan, Ohio, and Pennsylvania. These states generally apply the sales tax rate based on the seller’s location for intrastate sales. However, each state has exceptions and nuances, so businesses should verify local rules.
Does the Wayfair decision affect origin based sales tax states?
Yes, the Wayfair decision impacts origin based sales tax states by allowing them to enforce economic nexus. This means remote sellers who meet sales or transaction thresholds must collect tax—even without a physical presence—based on the rate at their own location.
Is origin-based or destination-based taxation better for e-commerce?
Destination-based taxation is generally considered more equitable for e-commerce, as it ensures tax is paid where the consumer resides. However, origin-based systems are simpler for sellers with a single location. Many experts believe destination-based models are the future of sales tax policy.
How do I know which tax rate to charge in an origin based state?
In an origin based sales tax state, you charge the combined state and local tax rate applicable to your business’s physical location. You can find this rate using your address on the state’s tax department website or through tax automation software.
Can a business be in both origin and destination states?
Yes. A business may sell into both origin based sales tax states and destination-based states. In that case, it must apply the correct tax model for each state—origin rules for states like Michigan and destination rules for states like California or New York.
Origin based sales tax states represent a shrinking but still significant segment of the U.S. sales tax landscape. While they offer simplicity for local businesses, they face growing pressure to adapt to the realities of digital commerce. Understanding how these states operate—along with their rules, challenges, and compliance requirements—is essential for any business selling across state lines. As policy continues to evolve, staying informed and leveraging technology will be key to long-term success.
Further Reading:
